In January 2025, the Palisades Fire ripped through the Santa Monica Mountains, destroying thousands of structures, displacing families, and upending the lives of entire communities.
In The New Yorker, writer Dana Goodyear recounts her own experience of losing her home—along with her children’s schooling, her family’s heirlooms, and the neighborhood she thought was safe.
But the story isn’t just about loss—it’s about the agonizing, slow, and deeply human journey of what happens after everything burns.
The Immediate Shock and Disorientation
Even before the worst flames arrive, warning signs had been building: dry conditions, fierce winds, depleted water reserves.
When fire finally struck, the retreat was chaotic, surreal:
The Goodyear family fled with only what they could grab, leaving behind journals, photographs, paintings, and belongings locked in what they thought were safe places.
After evacuating, they watched from afar as red-hot embers coursed down their street, consuming neighbor after neighbor’s home.
In the aftermath, when they returned, the street was flattened. Their house was gone—only a charred pit, a surviving elm tree, and some twisted metal remained.
Loss at that scale is not just material—it is spatial, emotional, temporal. The home ceases to be a refuge and becomes a void.
Legal, Financial, and Insurance Quagmires
Once the flames subside, another battlefield emerges: insurance claims, rebuild decisions, and community regulations.
Many homeowners, including Goodyear’s neighbors, were underinsured. The Deschanels (a neighboring family) had to rely on the California FAIR Plan, which caps payouts at amounts far below actual market value.
Some major insurers had already exited high-risk zones, detaching coverage from those who needed it most.
Homeowners must itemize every lost possession, often rebuilding a massive inventory from memory or clips. Goodyear refers to this process as creating a “Total Loss Memory Book.”
Meanwhile, as lots clear, developers eye opportunities: under laws permitting lot subdivision, some homes potentially will be replaced with duplexes, densifying what was once a low-density neighborhood.
Reconstruction is as much about courtrooms, permits, and architectures of regulation as it is about bricks and beams.
Health, Environment, and Hidden Dangers
Burned cities are not just landscapes in ruin—they can turn toxic.
The ash and air contain dangerous compounds (asbestos, lead, benzene, among others) that are not captured by conventional air-quality indices.
Water systems may backflow contaminated ash into pipes, triggering “do not drink” warnings even after the fire is out.
In the month after the fire, researchers estimated over 400 excess deaths in Los Angeles County related to stress, disrupted medical care, and poor air quality.
Mental health, not surprisingly, becomes a silent crisis. Survivors report nightmares, hypervigilance, grief over what was lost, and existential disorientation.
Recovery means rebuilding bodies and psyches as much as houses.
Rebuilding — With Caution, Innovation, and Legacy
Some households choose to walk away; others are rooted enough to try again. For those rebuilding, new strategies are emerging.
The Deschanels decided to rebuild—to recapture the memories held in their land, walls, and view.
Their new home design involves a fireproof shell using metal trusses and foam cores, wrapped in concrete, with AI systems that can mist interiors or prevent flooding.
Reconstruction is slower than many expect. In the Palisades, debris removal by the Army Corps of Engineers is only one step; many lots remain empty fields, waiting.
As parts of the community rebuild, neighborhoods risk being reshaped—not just physically but in density, character, and demographics.
The home that emerges may not look like what was lost—but it must contend with a new reality of climate risk.
What Broader Lessons Can We Draw?
Disasters are no longer rare outliers. What felt like an anomaly now feels inevitable. The question is: What systems can bend rather than break under repeated shocks?
Insurance and public infrastructure must evolve. When private insurers retreat, gaps emerge. State and municipal systems must fill them—better, faster, with foresight.
Communities are contested post-disaster terrains. Who returns, who sells out, who subdivides? The shape of a neighborhood is fought as much in planning offices as in the ashes.
Memory matters. Objects, heirlooms, photographs—they may be ephemeral, but they anchor identity and continuity.
Adaptive design and resilience need not compromise beauty. The Deschanels’ rebuild is intended to look much like the original, but with safety and future risk in mind.
Conclusion: From Ruin to Reckoning
Losing a home is more than catastrophic—it’s an inversion of all the implicit contracts we have with place, family, memory, and future.
In her essay, Goodyear shows us that the path forward is neither linear nor assured, but that rebuilding does more than restore shelter—it reconstructs meaning.
Ready to Protect What Matters Most?
Wildfires and natural disasters can strike without warning. Make sure your home and family are protected with the right coverage.
Want to explore your insurance needs? Get in touch with us today at 818.483.1360.
